Sunday, November 2, 2008

It's On! Rainshadow ponders the LotS premier.

Well, that fateful day has come… and now gone.

At long last, Legend of the Seeker, or at least the two-hour premier, has finally aired. Two long years in the making—and many more in the minds of those of us who dream of such things—and the creation is finally ours to embrace. In retrospect, those years seem all too short. I wouldn’t trade them for anything.

Before diving into the nitty-gritty, there seems to be a great boundary standing between the fans of the books who loved the show’s premier—rainshadow included—and those who are unable to forgive the many deviations that the series creators have taken from the author’s original vision. I’d personally be curious to hear Mr. Goodkind’s take. Of course, the show will never touch the mastery of Terry’s written word—nigh impossible even had the creators copied directly from the script of Wizard’s First Rule (WFR).

The fact of the matter is that Sam Raimi and Co. are using the blueprint of Terry’s marvelous tale. However, a blueprint is much like a skeleton, which must have the tendons and muscles and flesh and blood and all the organs therein, all capable of the routine biological processes, to sustain life, or it collapses. There are a number of reasons why the creators aren’t binding the blueprint to the same materials Terry used to breathe life into WFR.

Foremost, not every detail within Terry’s book translates very well to the screen. Indeed Terry’s written word is magnificent to behold. However, prose is boundless to all but the writer’s imagination, whereas television has its limitations. The screen allows only a portion of the whole to be revealed with each shot. The development of characters, for instance, is great for a novel because the use of narration is but one way to seamlessly bind events through a character’s thoughts. It gets tricky in television, especially when creators are hesitant to focus on details of the past in flashbacks. Flashbacks have a tendency to pause the flow of a story, and in an hour-long episode of a series that uses each episode to tell an independent story, they are a serious time killer. Therefore, when they are used in LotS, they will be used sparingly at most. After all… life is the future, not the past.

Another reason the creators are taking such liberties is that, while they want to remain true to the spirit of the books, they also want to give us a unique story. I was always a bit envious of the viewers LotS would attract who had not actually read the books—fans of Xena and Hercules spring instantly to mind, as they will be interested in what Raimi and his team have up their sleeves this time around. I want to see something new, as well, and while LotS isn’t the same WFR I once read and fell in love with back in high school, the balance is met in that I am seeing something, while familiar to me, wholly new as well. The idea that something so dear to me can bring a brand new excitement is an exhilarating realization. I love the idea of not knowing, even if I bear the burden of knowledge somewhere in between.

The third reason for the changes is a lot less story related, and perhaps a bit easier pill to swallow to some of those who have been uninterested in the generic medication of apples and oranges—heh… you PI nuts will understand that… the rest of you will have to wait for a future post.

The reason might ease your disgust at Terry for letting them touch his book, or vice versa. Perhaps it will strengthen your anger at the creators who in turn touched the story, or vice versa. For me, however, it was all too clear and acceptable a reason when a member of PI—who exactly I do not recall—pointed out that the writers are actually rewarded for their inventiveness. The more change, the more they breathe their own interpretations into the story, the more benefits they reap.

Who am I to argue with the reaping of benefits? As long as I remain as intrigued as I have been to the point, I will continue not to bitch.

Now we get to the meat of it. Like the alpha in a ravenous pack of bloodthirsty heart hounds, rainshadow descended on the remote a few minutes before 5 p.m. Central. And it turns out the fury before the storm was every bit as intense, if not more so, than the storm itself.

I turned on the tube to discover, horror of horrors, that on WGN, LotS actually aired at 4 p.m.

After a mega-hissy I soothed my fury (managing somehow not to kill the cat or destroy the house in a furious blood rage) when Zedd calmly reminded me that another channel was also scheduled to air the show at what I thought to be 5. Luckily enough, this time the info was spot on, and all was right in the world of rainshadow’s television viewing. Zedd was a happy pussycat, too.

Terror averted—though barely—rainshadow was able to watch the show, and within moments his fury was completely washed away in a mire of unabated bliss as I began to meet Kahlan, Richard, Zedd, and Chase all over again, with a touch of hatred for the villain who has been shed in a new light. It was the best two hours of my week, maybe the best in a great many weeks. The story was much more in tune to the books than many had feared as the time diminished from two years, to months, to weeks and even days and hours prior to the premier. The tone was deliciously accurate to the tone of WFR, even if many of the circumstances were often different.

I’ve seen some comments in regard to the “excessive” use of slow motion during the premier, and that is one of the things that strike me as perfect for this brand of series, especially considering Terry’s use of the perception of time within his novels. Elements are described in great detail as an event that would appear to happen in the blink of the eye go through a considerably in-depth telling in Terry’s novels… Richard cutting at bad guys with the Sword of Truth and Kahlan’s use of her power are key examples.

We are also beginning to see the edges of character development on the horizon… not an easy thing to accomplish in a show’s premier. A premier needs to draw viewers in by leaning heavily on the raw aspects of such a show. In this case, the raw aspects of LotS… the action and the plot take center stage while things such as character development, which will eventually begin to drive the series, must take a backseat for at least the premier. The creators will have time to tell us who these people are, but without intensity of the premier the average viewer would turn away much too quickly if they are bored.

I relished in homages aplenty toward the books; what they meant by some elements of future books being sprinkled into the storyline was true as toasted toads. I won’t name any of those situations here, for the sake of my readers who have yet to see the show, and for those who have yet to read the books. You’ll just have to take my word for it.

It pleased me greatly to see the creators had such respect for Terry and his works that even some of those scenes they couldn’t maintain in the flow of the show, they managed to honor in some small way.

By the way, if you’re a member of either party—or worse, both—what the hell are you doing here?! Go remedy!

Yes, yes, that’s not too easy for those of you who can’t watch the show to remedy. I’m truly sorry about that.

Some things do indeed suck.

One of these days (with any luck sooner rather than later), I hope everyone has a chance to enjoy the moment as I did. And I hope, when that day comes, that you find it as pleasing a time as me. I was a kid in a candy store, or at the very least, a gar on a fresh kill. A delicious feast it was, to be sure.

I’m ravenous for the next installment.

Until next time, may the good spirits be with you!

44 comments:

Steven Carroll said...

Very good, thought out response to the show. I also enjoyed it immensely and look forward to more every week.

Linayus said...

C'mon, RS, didn't you see all my posts about LOTS coming on at 4pm CST on WGN? lol

Heh, and I get to watch it again tonight on CW! And again Wed night on WGN (so you should too!).

Dare2bu said...

I too enjoyed the premiere. It was truly a new experiencewith old friends. I watched the show with a friend who has also read all the books and he also enjoyed the show. I got my brother and sister-in-law coming over this afternoon to watch it again. so hopefully two more converts.Keep up the blog I enjoy your take on the show/books/the world in general. For all those people who have problems with oranges and apples. Just have fruit salad.

Josh Borenstein said...

Goodkind is a hypocrite and a sellout. All these years of "waiting" for the right offer to come along - supposedly for the sake of staying true to the story. And yet what we've seen here is a bastardization of WFR. It's an abomination. Lots of cheesiness. Lots of deviation. Lots of fail.

Of course, I expect you'll delete this comment just like a good PI soldier and call me a troll. How dare fans compare the show to the books? Not like the books are relevant...

rainshadow said...

Thanks to those of you who are being pleasant.

Josh, I'm not going to delete your post. I don't mind opinions at all. I completely disagree with you, and your accusations toward me are completely unfounded. I am a PI mod but I run my own show here. This blog has nothing to do with PI.

Steven Carroll said...

This may sound odd, but what does PI stand for anyway?

Monica said...

Nice Blog, Rainshadow.

rainshadow said...

PI is Prophets-Inc... It's the same as terrygoodkind.com.

And thank you Monica.

ViridianIV said...

Oh the haters. Does Josh there even realize how Fanatic he sounds? I can think of a certain religious order with the same kind of blind rejection of a small amount of change.

XD, I wonder if you know who I am from PI!!!

P.S.

Check out my small picture hosting blog for some cool 3D renders of Mord-Sith my brother made for me!!

Josh Borenstein said...

LOL, a small amount of change? What show did you watch? If it's fanatical to want one of your favorite authors to have an ounce of artistic integrity, then by all means, call me a fanatic. Far better to have a critical eye than to be so easily appeased.

And saying that I sound like a religious nut because I don't settle for mediocrity is a huge non sequitur.

ViridianIV said...

Did any of you watch Ratatouille? I believe it basically said that critics weren't very important in the grand scheme of things because they risk very little.

Critical eyes will only bring you disapointment in everything you look at. And it wasn't all that different from the books.

It had large differences yes, but the main focus and drive of the story is still the same, and will likely remain the same.

If you don't want to watch it though, than here's a thought, don't.

P.S.

This is the last I will argue with you about it.

Dare2bu said...

I too was wondering what PI meant. never thought to ask the question though. DuH! ....maybe I thought they where just a group of ppl that loved the number 3.14...
Watched the show 3 times now. still love it and got 2 new converts in the form of my Brother and Sister-in-law. They never read the books so no preconcieved notions.(now got to get them to read those as well).

Steven Carroll said...

Hey Josh. Terry doesn't have anything to do with the show. He has no input whatsoever. Disney cut him out after getting what they wanted. So your blame being given to Terry is extremely misplaced.

Josh Borenstein said...

"Hey Josh. Terry doesn't have anything to do with the show. He has no input whatsoever. Disney cut him out after getting what they wanted. So your blame being given to Terry is extremely misplaced."

He signed off on it, didn't he? No one put a gun to his head. He put his FAITH in Disney, after lecturing readers in 11 books that faith is the epitome of stupidity.

Lethia said...

Come now, RS, leave us a list of all the things you noticed, I want to compare and contrast to see if I missed anything that was thrown up as homage for the books! Just put a spoiler tag on it, if people want to see spoilers, that's their choice. :D

Dare2bu said...

I agree with Lethia. I would Love to see what little things I might have missed or If I got them all.er

Steven Carroll said...

Actually Josh, Terry put his faith in Sam Raimi, who still goes to him for advise, but disney has the final say in how things turn out. Also, Faith can't be the epitome of stupidity, otherwise one cannot have Truth. You can't have friends without Faith. I think you might have missed the point he was trying to make. It was to not be blinded by Faith.

Josh Borenstein said...

"Also, Faith can't be the epitome of stupidity, otherwise one cannot have Truth."

What nonsense is this?

"You can't have friends without Faith."

The Hell you can't.

rainshadow said...

I'll have a list next Thursday night at the latest.

But they won't be going up on my blog. I'll be willing to email them.

I don't find anything wrong it what Terry's done. He's basically getting paid to have his show advertised. Like the show or not, it's going to attract interest in his books.

I have to laugh at calling Terry a sellout, frankly. Dear me, how could he POSSIBLY think to make money from his work?

I mean, that's like... criminal!

Josh Borenstein said...

Laugh all you want, but the joke's on us.

Sellout: a person who compromises his or her personal values, integrity, talent, or the like, for money or personal advancement.

If the shoe fits...

Dare2bu said...

RS - Yes i'd love that email

Josh - If the Shoe fits....guess Cinderella is a sellout too.

Steven Carroll said...

Hey Josh, if you don't have Faith (not meaning religious here) in your friends it means you don't trust them. If you don't trust them, they are not your friends. Thus, you need to have Faith, or can't have friends.

ViridianIV said...

If the shoe fits.....

Shove a sock in it.

Josh Borenstein said...

Looks like I struck a chord with you tools.

ViridianIV said...

The only chord you struck is the one that you stubbed your toe on as you made your way off your high horse.

Seriously, go away.

You didn't like it, we get that, now go and take your raincloud with you.

rainshadow said...

We here at rainshadow zoo like to feed our trolls.

Josh Borenstein said...

You must kill at comedy clubs.

Lethia said...

Josh.

You have a right to your opinion. RS will gladly allow you to post whatever that opinion is.

It's when you start calling people names, when you insult people, when you act callously, rudely, with no respect to this blog or to the people who come here to read RS, that is when you upset others.

I don't agree with some of what has been said towards you. They were equally wrong for insulting you or antagonizing you. However, your behaviour deserves some form of punishment, otherwise how will you learn? Hence, my lecture.

Now, hate Mr. Goodkind, the books, or the show, as much as you want, but by being rude to others, your opinion will only be laughed at an shrugged off, you will never be taken seriously, and you will be teased, insulted, and argued with for the rest of your posting life. If that is what you want, so be it.

And RS, wtf, this is RS unleashed, why can't you post the list on your blog? It's not unleashed if it's stiffled by the fear of spoilering people ;). :P

rainshadow said...

Here's the reason: I intend not to post any spoilers until at the very least after the first season.

I'm actually putting my list together for a certain member on PI that asked for my list publicly. It turns out that I will be posting it over on the forum that allows book spoilers on PI, which means I won't have to email.

:yay:

rainshadow said...

Josh:

I don't know if you pay attention over at PI... but people tend to think rainshadow is a pretty funny guy.

If you don't, I really don't care. Your just the resident troll. ;)

Actually, I don't see it as such. I think you're just another voice, kind've like a radical politician that nobody really likes but somehow manages to maintain his seat after every election.

I'll tolerate your views, I'll even tolerate you being argumentative.

But I'll RESPECT you if you can offer insight to support your views other than attacks.

It wasn't so much as Goodkind putting faith in Disney than Goodkind using Disney to expose his series to a wider audience. That is the main purpose being the series: to entice interest in and sell the books.

Many like it, many hate it. Feel free to stay on your side of the fence. I'm perfectly fine with the fact that there are people who dislike it. But I have to say, you don't provide any decent arguments in your one-man debate.

ViridianIV said...

"You must kill at Comedy Clubs"
-Josh Borenstein

I had a really great comeback all ready to go (It was a good one) but then I realized Rainshadow might not approve of lude comments, so I'll ask first.

Rainshadow, is it alright if I smack this dupe around for awhile? He's getting on my nerves.

Anonymous said...

Josh...would you like some cheese?
:D

Josh Borenstein said...

(Not my own words, but I agree with pretty much all of it)

First off, the casting was horrible. Richard was awful. Zedd was greasy and gross and brooding and terrible. Wheres the jokester, fun loving Zedd? Chase? Never once have I pictured him as a Polynesian man with a black wife. Maybe thats just me. Darken Rahl, a greasy dark haired Snape look alike. I mean, seriously? Is that necessary to change? Were the blond wigs too expensive?

The special effects were for the most part terrible. The arrows even looked bad. And you have plenty of chance to watch arrows since every arrow shot is in slow motion. The Boundary looked like Jell-O, the green screen work was just terrible, it looks so amateurish. And whats with the Wizard's Fire? Zedd used it all the time, and it just blew things up. Like he was throwing grenades. And the "climactic" battle at the end, with all the fire surrounding them, wow, could they not have used real fire?

What else. Story changes. They were ridiculous. The sword is hardly even important, its basically just any old sword, but it glows red sometimes!!!! Isn't the Sword a HUGE part of the story? Apparently not. It's not named, and it doesn't have TRUTH on the hilt. And when Richard is made Seeker he stands in a circle of fire, holds the sword high, and lightning comes from the sky striking the sword over and over, or vice versa, wasn't sure which angle they were going for here. Though, they probably didn't know either.

And what is with this Fein character? Killing George Cypher, kidnapping Chase's daughter, going to see Adie? So dumb. He takes the Book of Counted Shadows, and tries to get it back to Darken Rahl. And speaking of the book. It is essentially useless. Richard reads the first page, then doesn't look at it again. They never mention the Boxes of Orden, so I'm sure those have no part in this series. The book just holds "the secret to power", which is why Rahl wants it so bad apparently. Too bad he can't have it, it was destroyed in a fire, after which Zedd quipped "Well it appears as though the Seeker's destiny doesn't come with an instruction manual." Good writing there.

The battle scenes were dreadful, its like 300 on steroids with all the slow-mo. I should have counted all the slow-mo shots. When I thought of counting, I counted about 15 shots of slow-mo in a minute span. Then I just stopped counting. Richard jumps off rocks like every 2 seconds to chop somebody so they can have that slow-mo air shot with his sword held high in the air. And from what I've seen for previews for the upcoming episodes, he will continue to jump off more rocks.

Shar is a lightbulb basically. She died when she was hit with an arrow to protect Richard. The local militia, rounded up by Michael Cypher attacked Richard at a bridge, that was about 4 feet long standing over a small creek. They had quite a battle to get across the bridge. Shar gave up her life in battle so Richard could cross the small creek. Aw.

Adie was pretty much useless. And annoying. I'm not sure why they even included her in the show, because they didn't use her to get through the boundary. Oh no, they used other methods! Darken Rahl had about 20 men launch rocks that were set on fire at the boundary. Over and over and over. Eventually these rocks ripped right through the boundary, conveniently this is right where Richard and Kahlan were standing. Giving them a clear path through the boundary after that epic climactic battle I mentioned earlier. Kahlan also mentioned that Rahl had an army of Wizards and Sorcerers on his side, which I don't remember ever being in the book. But I could be wrong, its been a long time.

The writing was probably the worst part. There were tons of horribly cheesy lines. I wish I could remember them. After Richard killed a Gar to protect Chase's daughter, Chase says "If I believed in fairy tales, then I'd say, my friend, Richard Cypher, just slayed a dragon. Thank you." Good job.

**END SPOILERS**

I don't understand most of these changes. Well I don't understand any of them really. In no way does it make sense to dumb down his best book, to try to get more people interested in it. If I was dumb enough to enjoy that type of cheese-fest show, and then had to read a far darker, more serious book, I would probably hate the book. In fact, I probably wouldn't even be able to tackle a book over 200 pages.

It's sad how horribly this all went wrong. Goodkind is probably one of the biggest sell outs of all time. Though I hated his later books, at least I could respect him a bit for not wanting to whore his work out to the highest bidder so they could change his stories at will. Well, maybe he was low on money, because he definitely fucked up on this one. I mean, did he have NOTHING at all to do with this production? Did Sam Raimi come to him and say "You know what Terry, I'm going to change everything!" to which Goodkind surely replied, "Sounds good! Wheres my money?"

Steven Carroll said...

No, Terry wasn't involved in teh creation of this series really. I also must say that I disagree with most of the comments made there. I can see the points of a few, but not most. To each their own. I for liked the show and look forward to more. It is too bad that you didn't.

ViridianIV said...

Wow, if I didn't know any better I'd think Josh was expecting a movie Budget! The SFX were fine for a syndicated TV series. Zedd was pretty much the only character in the show who cracked any kinds of jokes.

I could go on, but I'd only be enabling him.

ViridianIV said...

"You know what Terry, I'm going to change everything!"

Everything? I guess you didn't notice any of these

-Kahlan attacked by four men, Richard rescuing her.

-A boundary dividing the Midlands and Westlands.

-Character names

-Locations names

-a Sword of Truth

-Gar's

-Zedd's love of food

-Darkan Rahl's lip rubbing mannerism

-The People's Palace (Which looked awesome)

-etc. etc.

Plenty is the same, it only falls flat if you expected a direct translation.

Josh Borenstein said...

And those pesky Boxes of Orden, obviously not integral to the story. They don't even come up all that much. Especially later on. No, "secrets to power" is much better.

Please.

ViridianIV said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
ViridianIV said...

Read some interviews and you'll know the Boxes play a large role in it. Series's don't reveal everything in the first two episodes, nor do books reveal everything in the first 50 pages.

The Boxes of Orden hold the POWER of Orden, so 'the secret's of power' is a perfectly acceptable description, especially if you want to save the reveal to the masses that the book is a tech guide to opening some boxes to a later episode.

Learn some patience, wait for the season to end, THEN complain about what isn't there, not when there are still 20 episodes that you don't know anything about.

stopucrying said...

Read all of the books at least once and LOVE the show. Now my husband wants to read the series. As for me, someone who didn’t expect the show to = the book, integrity of the main characters is apparent. The rest is icing.

rainshadow said...

Josh: so rather than make your own statements you pick a random post from someone else to do it for you?

That's fine. Really. I guess.

Not everyone can make their own argument.

Josh Borenstein said...

"Josh: so rather than make your own statements you pick a random post from someone else to do it for you?

That's fine. Really. I guess.

Not everyone can make their own argument."

It wasn't a random post. It came from someone I respect who has good taste.

You want an argument from me? Post your second glowing review, and I'll give you one. Ass.

ViridianIV said...

Funny how people can only protest with swear words.

To: Josh

Subject: Ass

Take a look in the mirror, learn to protest without a jumble of insults and tantrums and maybe one day someone will listen to you.

Gee its STILL raining in here for some reason???

rainshadow said...

Josh, I can think of plenty of people who dislike the series for many of the same reasons as you. I would be glad to show you some of their reviews, tell you why I respect them, and attribute that post to them.

It is a random post to me. I don't have an attribution to go off of.

Thank you for trying.

Signed,
The Ass

P.S. You're right about one thing, I can be an Ass.